Competitive Analysis Guide

Who Are Your Competitorson Etsy?

Knowing your competition is the first step to beating them. This guide shows you how to identify, analyze, and learn from competitors to grow your Etsy shop.

Find direct competitorsAnalyze pricing strategiesLearn from top sellersIdentify market gapsTrack competitor changesImprove your listings
Analyze Competitors FreeHow to Find Competitors

Quick Navigation

Why Track Competitors?Types of CompetitorsHow to Find ThemWhat to AnalyzeStep-by-Step ProcessDo's and Don'tsHelpful ToolsYour Action PlanAll FAQs

Why Track Your Competitors?

Understanding your competition isn't about copying—it's about making smarter decisions.

💵

Validate Your Pricing

Know if you're priced too high or leaving money on the table. Understanding market rates helps you price competitively while maintaining profit margins.

🎯

Spot Market Gaps

Find opportunities your competitors are missing. Maybe there's a color they don't offer, a customization option in demand, or a related product that would sell.

📚

Learn Best Practices

Successful competitors have tested what works. Learn from their photography, descriptions, and customer service without making the same mistakes.

📈

Anticipate Trends

Watch what top sellers are launching. Their new products often signal where the market is heading.

🔍

Improve SEO

See which keywords successful listings target. Understand how competitors structure titles and tags to rank well.

✨

Differentiate Your Brand

To stand out, you need to know what you're standing out FROM. Competitor research reveals how to position your unique value.

Three Types of Competitors

Not all competitors are the same. Understanding the differences helps you prioritize your research.

🎯

Direct Competitors

Shops selling identical or very similar products to yours

Examples:

  • •Same product category
  • •Same price range
  • •Same target customer
  • •Competing for same keywords

High - These directly impact your sales and search rankings

🔄

Indirect Competitors

Shops selling different products that solve the same customer need

Examples:

  • •Alternative gift options
  • •Different styles/aesthetics
  • •Substitute products
  • •Different materials

Medium - Customers might choose them instead of you

⭐

Aspirational Competitors

Top-performing shops you want to learn from and eventually match

Examples:

  • •Star Sellers in your niche
  • •Shops with 10k+ sales
  • •Shops featured in Etsy Picks
  • •Influential shop brands

Medium - Great for learning best practices

How to Find Your Competitors

1

Search Your Main Keywords

Open Etsy and search for keywords your customers would use. Note shops appearing in the first 2-3 pages of results—these are competing for the same traffic.

Pro tip: Search in incognito mode to avoid personalized results.

2

Browse "Related Shops"

On any competitor's shop page, scroll down to see "People who viewed this also viewed" suggestions. These are algorithmically-determined similar shops.

Pro tip: This feature surfaces shops customers consider alternatives to you.

3

Check Category Bestsellers

Navigate to your product category and sort by "Bestselling." The top shops here are market leaders worth studying.

Pro tip: Bestseller status indicates proven demand for that product type.

4

Search Social Platforms

Search Pinterest, Instagram, and TikTok for your product type. Note which Etsy shops appear in recommendations or have engaged followings.

Pro tip: Shops active on social media often set trends in their niche.

5

Use Shop Analyzer Tools

Tools like InsightAgent's Shop Analyzer let you search by product type and see estimated sales, helping identify successful competitors you might miss manually.

Pro tip: Data-driven competitor discovery is more comprehensive than manual search alone.

What to Analyze About Competitors

Focus your research on these four key areas:

📦

Product Strategy

  • What products are bestsellers?
  • How many product variations?
  • Price points and ranges
  • New product release frequency
  • Bundling and upsells
📝

Listing Quality

  • Title structure and keywords
  • Description format and length
  • Photo quality and style
  • Tag selection
  • Attributes used
💰

Pricing & Value

  • Base price vs. market average
  • Shipping strategy (free vs. paid)
  • Sale frequency and discounts
  • Customization pricing
  • Premium vs. budget positioning
🤝

Customer Experience

  • Review sentiment and patterns
  • Response time to messages
  • Shipping speed and packaging
  • Return/refund policies
  • Communication style

Your Competitor Analysis Process

Phase 1: Discovery (Week 1)

  • • Identify 10-15 potential competitors using methods above
  • • Create a spreadsheet with columns for shop name, URL, niche, estimated sales, star rating
  • • Narrow down to 5-10 to track regularly

Phase 2: Deep Analysis (Week 2-3)

  • • Analyze each competitor's top 5 listings in detail
  • • Document their pricing strategy, photo style, title patterns
  • • Read 20+ reviews per competitor to understand customer sentiment
  • • Note unique selling propositions and brand positioning

Phase 3: Apply Insights (Week 4+)

  • • Identify 3-5 actionable improvements for your shop
  • • Update listings based on keyword and title patterns observed
  • • Adjust pricing if significantly out of market range
  • • Develop your unique positioning based on gaps found

Ongoing: Regular Monitoring

  • • Weekly: Quick check on 2-3 key competitors
  • • Monthly: Update your competitor spreadsheet
  • • Quarterly: Full competitive audit, refresh competitor list

Competitor Analysis: Do's and Don'ts

DO

  • ✓Learn from their strategies, not their designs
  • ✓Document findings in a structured spreadsheet
  • ✓Focus on understanding WHY something works
  • ✓Look for gaps they're not filling
  • ✓Set a regular research schedule
  • ✓Turn insights into your own unique approach

DON'T

  • ✗Copy designs, photos, or descriptions directly
  • ✗Obsess over competitors daily
  • ✗Let research paralyze your action
  • ✗Undercut prices to compete (race to bottom)
  • ✗Ignore your own unique strengths
  • ✗Track too many competitors (overwhelm)

Tools for Competitor Analysis

Free Tools

  • •
    Etsy Search:Manual research of competitors and keywords
  • •
    Google Alerts:Monitor competitor brand mentions
  • •
    Google Sheets:Organize competitor tracking data
  • •
    Social Media Search:Find competitors on Pinterest, Instagram

InsightAgent (Recommended)

  • ✓
    Shop Analyzer:Track competitor sales and trends over time
  • ✓
    Keyword Research:See keywords competitors rank for
  • ✓
    Trends Explorer:Spot rising trends before competitors
  • ✓
    Listing Optimizer:Compare your listings to top performers
Try InsightAgent Free →

Your Competitor Analysis Action Plan

This Week

  1. 1. Search your main keywords
  2. 2. List 10 potential competitors
  3. 3. Create tracking spreadsheet
  4. 4. Narrow to 5-10 key competitors

This Month

  1. 1. Deep-analyze top 5 listings each
  2. 2. Read 20+ reviews per competitor
  3. 3. Document pricing strategies
  4. 4. Identify market gaps

Ongoing

  1. 1. Weekly quick checks
  2. 2. Monthly spreadsheet updates
  3. 3. Apply insights to your shop
  4. 4. Quarterly full audits
Start Analyzing Competitors

Frequently Asked Questions

Everything you need to know about competitor analysis on Etsy.

Start by searching for keywords your target customers would use. Note the shops that appear on the first 2-3 pages—these are your direct competitors. Look for shops selling similar products, targeting the same audience, and appearing in similar search results. Use Etsy's "People who viewed this also viewed" section to find related shops. Group competitors into tiers: direct (same products, same niche), indirect (similar products, overlapping audience), and aspirational (successful shops you want to emulate).
Focus on five key areas: (1) Product offerings - what items sell best, price ranges, variations offered. (2) Listing optimization - titles, tags, descriptions, photography style. (3) Pricing strategy - are they premium, mid-range, or budget? Do they bundle or offer discounts? (4) Customer experience - reviews, response time, policies, shipping options. (5) Marketing - social media presence, Pinterest activity, email marketing. Document findings in a spreadsheet for easy comparison.
For most sellers, tracking 5-10 competitors is optimal. Include: 2-3 direct competitors (similar size, same niche), 2-3 market leaders (top sellers you aspire to match), 2-3 newer shops (to spot emerging trends). Tracking too many becomes overwhelming and time-consuming. Quality analysis of fewer competitors beats superficial analysis of many. Revisit your list quarterly as the market evolves.
Look for these signals: (1) Review count - more reviews generally means more sales. (2) "Bestseller" badges - Etsy marks top-selling items. (3) Star Seller status - indicates consistent sales and positive reviews. (4) Listing age vs reviews - newer listings with many reviews are selling fast. (5) Sold count - some shops display this. Use tools like InsightAgent's Shop Analyzer to track competitor sales estimates and identify their top performers over time.
Never copy directly—this is unethical and potentially illegal (copyright/trademark infringement). Instead: (1) Learn from their strategies, not their designs. (2) Understand WHY something works, then create your own version. (3) Use competitor research to identify market gaps they're not filling. (4) Improve on their weaknesses. (5) Find your unique angle that differentiates you. The goal is inspiration and market understanding, not imitation.
Create a regular schedule: Weekly - quick check on 2-3 key competitors for new products or price changes. Monthly - deeper analysis of all tracked competitors, update your comparison spreadsheet. Quarterly - full competitive audit, refresh your competitor list, identify new threats. Set Google Alerts for competitor shop names. Don't obsess daily—it's counterproductive. Spend 80% of time on your own shop, 20% max on competitor research.
Several approaches work: (1) Search Etsy for your product, note what titles/tags successful listings use. (2) Use Etsy's search autocomplete to find popular search terms. (3) Check competitor listings' source code for meta tags (right-click, "View Page Source"). (4) Use InsightAgent's keyword research tool to analyze what keywords drive traffic to top shops. (5) Look at competitor reviews for language customers use. Document common patterns across successful listings.
Free options: (1) Etsy search - manual research. (2) Google Alerts - track competitor mentions. (3) Spreadsheets - organize findings. Paid tools: (1) InsightAgent - shop analyzer, sales tracking, keyword research. (2) eRank - basic competitor data. (3) Marmalead - keyword analysis. InsightAgent is particularly useful for tracking competitor shops over time and seeing sales estimates. The investment pays off by saving research time and providing data you can't get manually.
Don't compete directly—find your edge: (1) Niche down - be THE shop for a specific subcategory they overlook. (2) Better customer service - faster responses, more personalization. (3) Unique offerings - customization options, bundles, exclusive designs. (4) Stronger brand story - connect emotionally with your audience. (5) Better photos or descriptions - quality they haven't matched. (6) Faster shipping or more options. (7) Target underserved customer segments. Compete on value, not just price.
Watch for: (1) Increasing discounts or constant sales. (2) Declining review frequency. (3) Stale inventory - same products for months. (4) Slow response times (check by messaging). (5) Negative review patterns increasing. (6) Removing listings. (7) Inconsistent activity. These might indicate opportunities in their market segment. But be cautious—could also mean the niche itself is declining.
Some copying is inevitable on Etsy. Protect yourself: (1) Build a strong brand that's hard to replicate. (2) Continuously innovate—be the trendsetter, not the follower. (3) Trademark your brand name and logo. (4) Copyright your original designs and descriptions. (5) Watermark preview images. (6) Create loyal customer relationships through excellent service. (7) Report clear intellectual property violations to Etsy. Focus more energy on staying ahead than on worrying about copycats.
Systematic approach: (1) Analyze top 10 listings for your main keyword. (2) Note common elements in successful titles. (3) Study their photography angles, props, backgrounds. (4) Read their descriptions - what benefits do they emphasize? (5) Check their tags (view page source). (6) Read their reviews - what do customers praise? (7) Identify what they're missing that you could offer. (8) A/B test changes based on findings. Improve one element at a time to measure impact.

Related Guides for Etsy Sellers

How to Analyze Etsy Competitors

Detailed competitor analysis methodology.

Etsy Keyword Research Guide

Master keyword research to boost visibility.

Etsy Market Research Guide

Learn to analyze markets and find niches.

Competitive analysis should be used for learning and improvement, never for copying or intellectual property infringement. Always create original work that reflects your unique brand and value proposition.

Ready to Outperform Your Competition?

InsightAgent gives you the tools to analyze competitors, track market trends, and optimize your listings—so you can stay one step ahead.

Start Free TrialExplore Features