Etsy Alternatives for Digital Products

Where to Sell Digital ProductsLike Etsy

Etsy isn't your only option. Compare 15 platforms for selling digital downloads—from marketplaces with built-in traffic to self-hosted solutions with full control.

15 Etsy alternativesAll product typesBuilt-in traffic optionsSelf-hosted optionsNiche marketplacesPrice comparison

The Quick Answer

There are 3 main categories of platforms

🛒

Marketplaces

Built-in traffic, higher fees

Etsy, Creative Market, Amazon

👤

Creator Platforms

Low fees, bring your own traffic

Gumroad, Payhip, Ko-fi

🏠

Self-Hosted

Full control, monthly costs

Shopify, WooCommerce

Best strategy: Start on a marketplace (Etsy) for discovery, add a creator platform (Gumroad) for your audience, consider self-hosted when you scale.

Marketplaces with Built-in Traffic

These platforms have buyers already looking for products—you trade higher fees for traffic

🛒

Etsy

Traffic: High | Fees: ~13% total

Best for:

Printables, patterns, templates, craft supplies

Audience:

90M+ buyers, craft-focused

Pros:

  • + Massive traffic
  • + Trusted brand
  • + Built-in SEO

Cons:

  • - High competition
  • - Fee increases
  • - Algorithm changes
🎨

Creative Market

Traffic: High | Fees: 40% commission

Best for:

Fonts, graphics, templates, themes

Audience:

Designers, agencies, businesses

Pros:

  • + Professional audience
  • + Quality reputation
  • + Premium prices

Cons:

  • - High commission
  • - Approval required
  • - Design-focused only
📚

Amazon KDP

Traffic: Very High | Fees: 30-65% royalty cut

Best for:

Ebooks, journals, low-content books

Audience:

Book readers worldwide

Pros:

  • + Huge market
  • + Print option
  • + Kindle ecosystem

Cons:

  • - Book format only
  • - Strict guidelines
  • - Competition
💻

Envato Market

Traffic: High | Fees: 37.5-55% commission

Best for:

Themes, plugins, graphics, video, audio

Audience:

Developers, video creators, agencies

Pros:

  • + High-ticket items
  • + Recurring buyers
  • + Professional

Cons:

  • - Technical products
  • - High commission
  • - Quality bar

Creator Platforms (Bring Your Own Traffic)

Lower fees but you need to drive your own buyers—perfect when you have an audience

💳

Gumroad

Traffic: Low | Fees: 10% (free) / 5% (paid)

Best for:

Ebooks, courses, music, software, templates

Pros:

  • + Simple
  • + Email tools
  • + Memberships

Cons:

  • - No marketplace traffic
  • - Basic storefront
💰

Payhip

Traffic: Low | Fees: 5% + processing

Best for:

Digital downloads, memberships, coaching

Pros:

  • + Low 5% fee
  • + EU VAT handling
  • + Affiliates

Cons:

  • - No traffic
  • - Less known

Ko-fi

Traffic: Low | Fees: 0-5%

Best for:

Art, commissions, creator content

Pros:

  • + 0% on tips
  • + Community
  • + Free tier

Cons:

  • - Smaller scale
  • - Fan-focused
🎓

Teachable

Traffic: Low | Fees: Free plan + 10%

Best for:

Online courses, coaching, memberships

Pros:

  • + Course features
  • + Free plan
  • + Professional

Cons:

  • - Course-focused
  • - Limited free tier

Self-Hosted Options (Full Control)

Own your platform, your data, and your customer relationships

Shopify

$29-299/mo

Full e-commerce, Digital Downloads app, apps ecosystem

Best for:

Serious businesses, brand building, high volume

WooCommerce

Free (hosting $5-50/mo)

WordPress plugin, full control, many extensions

Best for:

Existing WordPress sites, technical users, full ownership

Squarespace

$16-49/mo

Beautiful templates, digital products, member areas

Best for:

Design-focused brands, portfolios with shop

Niche-Specific Platforms

Bandcamp

Music and audio

Fee: 10-15%

MyFonts

Fonts exclusively

Fee: Varies

Ravelry

Knitting/crochet patterns

Fee: Free for patterns

Adobe Stock

Photos, vectors, video

Fee: 33-35%

Lemon Squeezy

Software, SaaS

Fee: 5%

Which Platform for Your Product?

Product TypeBest Platforms
Printables & PlannersEtsy, Gumroad, Payhip
Ebooks & GuidesAmazon KDP, Gumroad, Payhip
Online CoursesTeachable, Gumroad, Kajabi
Design TemplatesCreative Market, Etsy, Canva
FontsCreative Market, MyFonts
Website ThemesEnvato, Creative Market
Music & AudioBandcamp, DistroKid, Gumroad
PhotographyAdobe Stock, iStock, Etsy
Software & PluginsGumroad, Lemon Squeezy
Notion TemplatesGumroad, Etsy, Payhip

Fee Comparison: What You Keep on a $20 Sale

PlatformTypeYou Keep
PayhipCreator~$18.40
Gumroad (paid plan)Creator~$18.40
Lemon SqueezyCreator~$18.40
Gumroad (free)Creator~$17.40
EtsyMarketplace~$17.00
Creative MarketMarketplace~$12.00
EnvatoMarketplace~$10.50

* Approximate after all fees including payment processing (~2.9% + $0.30)

Recommended Multi-Platform Strategy

1

Start with a Marketplace

Use Etsy or Creative Market to get discovered. Accept higher fees as marketing cost.

2

Add a Creator Platform

Once you have repeat customers, direct them to Gumroad or Payhip for lower fees.

3

Consider Self-Hosted

When volume justifies it, add Shopify or WooCommerce for full brand control.

Research Digital Trends on Etsy

Frequently Asked Questions

Everything you need to know about selling digital products beyond Etsy.

The best Etsy alternatives depend on your product type. For general digital products: Gumroad (ebooks, courses), Creative Market (design assets), Payhip (low fees). For specific niches: Amazon KDP (ebooks), Envato (themes/templates), Bandcamp (music), Teachable (courses). For control: Shopify, WooCommerce, or Squarespace. Each platform has different fees, audiences, and features. Many sellers use multiple platforms.
Yes, Etsy remains valuable for digital products, especially printables, patterns, and creative templates. Advantages: 90+ million active buyers, strong SEO, trusted brand. Disadvantages: ~12-15% fees, increasing competition, algorithm changes. Etsy works best when combined with other platforms. The built-in traffic is worth the higher fees if you optimize your listings well.
Gumroad is a creator-focused platform for selling digital products, memberships, and courses. Comparison: Gumroad has lower fees (10% vs Etsy's ~13%), simpler interface, built-in email marketing, and membership features. However, Gumroad has no built-in marketplace traffic—you must bring your own audience. Etsy has massive built-in traffic but higher fees. Best approach: use Etsy for discovery, Gumroad for your established audience.
Yes, through specific Amazon programs: (1) Amazon KDP for ebooks and print books (free, 35-70% royalty), (2) Amazon Merch for print-on-demand designs (invitation only), (3) Amazon Associates affiliate products. You cannot list general digital downloads like you would on Etsy. Amazon excels for ebooks but isn't suitable for printables, templates, or graphics. Consider Amazon KDP alongside Etsy for ebook-style content.
Creative Market is a curated marketplace for design assets: fonts, graphics, templates, themes, photos, and add-ons. It's ideal for professional designers creating assets for other creatives and businesses. Pros: high-quality audience willing to pay premium prices, established traffic. Cons: 40% commission (high), strict quality requirements, approval process. Best for: designers with professional-quality work who want passive income.
Consider Shopify if: you want full brand control, have your own traffic source, want to build long-term customer relationships, or plan significant volume. Shopify costs $29-299/month plus payment fees. Unlike Etsy, there's no built-in marketplace traffic—you need marketing. Many sellers use both: Etsy for discovery and new customers, Shopify for repeat buyers and brand building. Shopify's Digital Downloads app enables digital product delivery.
Platforms with significant built-in buyer traffic: (1) Etsy - 90M+ buyers, best for crafty/creative products, (2) Creative Market - millions of designers, best for design assets, (3) Amazon KDP - massive book market, (4) Envato/ThemeForest - developers and designers, (5) Redbubble/Society6 - print-on-demand, (6) iStock/Shutterstock - stock media. Other platforms (Gumroad, Payhip, Shopify) require you to drive your own traffic.
Consider these factors: (1) Product type - match your product to the platform's audience, (2) Traffic - need buyers? choose marketplace. Have audience? self-hosted works, (3) Fees - compare total costs including payment processing, (4) Features - email marketing, memberships, analytics needs, (5) Control - brand customization, customer data ownership. Start with 1-2 platforms, measure results, then expand. Many successful sellers use 3-5 platforms.
Social platforms offer various selling options: (1) Instagram - link in bio to store, shoppable posts, (2) TikTok Shop - growing commerce features, (3) Pinterest - shop integration, product pins, (4) Facebook - shops and marketplace. However, social platforms are better for promotion than hosting. Best practice: use social media to drive traffic to your store (Etsy, Gumroad, Shopify) rather than selling directly. Exceptions: simple tip-based sales via Ko-fi or Buy Me a Coffee.
Lowest fee platforms: (1) WooCommerce - free plugin, just payment processing (~2.9%), (2) Payhip - 5% + payment fees, (3) Lemon Squeezy - 5% + payment fees, (4) Gumroad - 10% on free plan, 5% on paid plans, (5) Ko-fi - 0% on tips, 5% on shop. Compare to Etsy (~13%) and Creative Market (40%). Lower fees usually mean less/no built-in traffic—you trade marketing costs for platform fees.
Yes, in most cases. Most platforms allow non-exclusive listings. Best practices: (1) Check each platform's exclusivity terms (some offer better rates for exclusives), (2) Use consistent pricing or strategic variation, (3) Customize descriptions for each platform's SEO, (4) Track which platforms perform best, (5) Consider exclusive launches on one platform then expanding. Creative Market offers higher royalties for exclusive products.
Product-platform matching: Printables/planners - Etsy, Gumroad. Ebooks - Amazon KDP, Gumroad, Payhip. Online courses - Teachable, Gumroad, Kajabi. Design assets - Creative Market, Envato. Fonts - Creative Market, MyFonts. Music - Bandcamp, DistroKid. Photography - Adobe Stock, iStock, Etsy. Software - Gumroad, Lemon Squeezy. Notion templates - Gumroad, Etsy. Craft patterns - Etsy, Ravelry.

Platform fees, features, and policies change frequently. Always verify current information on each platform's official website before making decisions.

Ready to Find Your Best-Selling Digital Products?

InsightAgent helps you discover trending digital products on Etsy, analyze what sells, and find the keywords that convert—so you can create products buyers actually want.